User talk:GublerjonesEdit This Page

From FamilySearch Wiki

Talk Conventions

  • Please post new messages at the bottom of the page to prevent confusion.
  • Please sign your comments. Type ~~~~ after your text.
  • Please use section headings to separate conversation topics.

See: Wikiquette, Be nice, and Talk page guidelines.

Start a new talk topic.

Hello Daniel Jones,

We appreciate the extensive work you have done on the Zurich parishes pages.

It has been noted that the ‎Wiedikon parish, Zürich, Switzerland page has been "Blanked". It is preferable to place a Delete template on an erroneous page. If the spelling or other part of the title is in error it is preferable to create a new page with the correct title and Redirect the page with the incorrect title to the one with the correct title. It is never appropriate to "Blank" a page. Please revisit the ‎Wiedikon parish, Zürich, Switzerland and take appropriate action. Parrisl 01:39, 9 February 2014 (UTC)

Welcome, Gublerjones,

We are happy that you have joined the research community of FamilySearch Research Wiki. We want to help you enjoy your involvement in this wiki community. Thank you for contributing to the Wolfhalden parish, Appenzell, Switzerland in the Research Wiki.

You are not alone. I am one of several people on the Welcoming Committee for FamilySearch Wiki. Each of us wants to make your time on the Wiki a fulfilling, and worthwhile experience.

As a new contributor, you may feel a little overwhelmed at the scope of the Wiki. If and when you need help please contact me (Hncamp) for assistance. If I don’t know the answer, I will find someone who does.

You are NEEDED and WANTED
Review the Wiki Tour to get you started and help

Thanks again and welcome aboard,
Hncamp 15:18, 7 May 2013 (UTC)
PS: I appreciate your contributions and the work you are doing on the FamilySearch Wiki! Remember that as part of our Community you are contributing to its quality. A worldwide community, contributing information for which they are experts, can provide a repository of genealogical excellence and unrivaled information for the entire world. Hncamp 10:18, 7 May 2013 (CDT)

Contents

Bern vs Berne, Switzerland

Hello,

One of my tasks is to review new pages.  When you were adding parishes in Bern, Switzerland, several of them had the spelling in the title as BERNE ( as opposed to BERN ).  Being unfamiliar with Switzerland myself, I did not know if this was done purposefully. You can review your edits and creations at this linkLinda R Chappell 22:41, 26 February 2014 (UTC)

Hello Linda,

The canton of Bern is bilingual, with the majority of parishes speaking German and a minority speaking French.  I have chosen to differentiate the different parishes based on the language used at the parish level.  Thus, the parish of Habkern would have called it Bern, while the parish of La Ferrière would have called it Berne.  The cantonal page will be organized under the dominant language (so it would be Bern instead of Berne, and Fribourg instead of Freiburg).— Preceding unsigned comment added by Gublerjones (talk | contribs) 27 February 2014 17:47

Dear Daniel, 

Thanks for the clarity. I will let the others on the Wiki team know. It's nice to have a specialist working on these pages.Linda R Chappell 19:50, 27 February 2014 (UTC)


Geographic maps Switzerland

I put a map on the Aarwangen_parish,_Bern,_Switzerland#Surrounding_Parishes. I would like to get input into how this looks. The only question I have is the name assigned to Aarwangen as Aarwangen parish instead of just Aarwangen. There needs to be a way to distinguish between a kirchgemeinde and a gemeinde. I don't know if putting parish in the title in the best way. Once the gemeinde pages are developed they will link to the kirchgemeinde or parish so a person will know where the church records will be found. Donjgen 05:03, 9 April 2014 (UTC)

I used wikipedia to determine how the parishes are aligned. The only question I have is the Solothurn parishes above Aarwangen. They were mostly Catholic, so I'm not sure how the Swiss reform church was organized in the Catholic areas of Solothurn. I see that familysearch has not filmed the Swiss reform records in Catholic areas. The clickable maps would be a nice addition to the pages. I wonder that perhaps the bezirks should be organized as they were 100 or 150 years ago, since we are trying get a historical perspective of the region as it was when our ancestors lived there. That would set it apart from wikipedia which has the districts well covered. Oberaargau is the district that Aarwangen is in now but previously it was its own district. Aarwangen district or bezirk covered quite a large area back then. Donjgen 06:09, 10 April 2014 (UTC)

I am sure that the parishes above Aarwangen are Catholic since familysearch has filmed the registers and they are 75% Catholic today.
There is nothing on the wiki now that is dynamic enough to go three layers deep in a Geographic location map, so it wouldn't work to include gemeinden with Kirchgemeinden on the same map. The gemeinden can have there own maps that point to surrounding gemeinden. The bezirks basically group parishes and places in the same area, so I'm not sure of the importance of this. I'm not sure if there are specific record groups that were kept at the bezirk level.
What do you think of the table I created for the a district in Solothurn?, Switzerland_Solothurn_Gazetteers. I was researching in that area and needed a map to sort out the area, so I created that.
On the Kilchberg_parish,_Zürich,_Switzerland you don't separate out the gemeinden places from the hamlets.
I've added a number of Geographic location maps up in the Aarwangen area and will keep doing that for now. I don't read German, so when it comes to reading gazetteers I'm not much help. I notice the extensive work you've done on Vechigen. Does the library have the source material for the place names and number of houses for every parish in Bern for 1838? What is the source? Donjgen 21:31, 13 April 2014 (UTC)

Geographic maps Gemienden Switzerland

I created a map for Busswil bei Melchnau, Bern, Switzerland. Is a separate page going to be created for Melchnau as a gemeinde or Municipality or is the parish page going to cover both? That is going to be an issue with all the kirchegemeinden as they are also a gemeinde. Donjgen 06:29, 27 April 2014 (UTC)

Gemeinde vs Municipality

While a gemeinde is translated in German to mean Municipality it is far from clear to an American what the differences are. A gemeinde is a ancestral home or heimat which is the basis for Swiss research over the decades. Thats the pitfall of Swiss research of the past is that everyone is born and or married in their heimat regardless of where they lived. A person hasn't been to there gemeinde for generations yet the genealogical records say they were born there and lived there and never left. Next to understanding the concept of parishes in Switzerland is the concept of the Gemeinden. In genealogical terms Municipality is a poor translation for Gemeinde for Switzerland, so I would suggest that Municipality be fazed out or secondary to the real term or meaning, Gemeinde. Something like on Busswil_bei_Melchnau,_Bern,_Switzerland uses a mouseover text to describe the meaning. Donjgen 01:39, 4 May 2014 (UTC)
" Thats the downfall pitfall of Swiss research of the past is that everyone is born and or married in their heimat regardless of where they lived. A person hasn't been to there gemeinde for generations yet the genealogical records say they were born there and lived there and never left."
In this statement I'm not referring to the parish registers. I'm referring to the compiled genealogies and group sheets that form the genealogies on familytree. Its only been within the past 20 years that Bern Canton registers have been available to those outside of Switzerland.

"This is no downfall, but actually a huge help for researching, as it means that you can identify where a family is living based on the records of their parish of citizenship." The problem it creates is families are put out of context with others that actually lived there. So when you see a Swiss group sheet you don't know whether it is a birthplace or place of citizenship. I was looking at the Stettler family in Bolligen. A large family in the 1740's and 1750's. Come to find out they went to Oberdiessbach in 1735 never to return. There is no clue in any of the group-sheets or compiled genealogies that this occurred. When I discovered this, new connections were made, old thought to be connections were dissolved. Johannes Stettler, my ancestor, is the only one to return to Bolligen. But there are 2 other Johannes who were actually born there that could be him. More research needs to be done.
In the future it would be best to not put everyone in one basket based on citizenship, but it would be best to accurately put people in place and time.
The next problem this creates is when I search for my Bolligen ancestors that lived in Oberdiessbach in familytree it don't find them because I changed there birthplace to Oberdiessbach. I put their place of citizenship in the section, 'other information', but apparently that doesn't help the search engine.
As the record keeping of the past I would but the place of citizenship as the birthplace and the section, 'other information' I would put the birthplace. Donjgen 18:58, 14 May 2014 (UTC)

"As the record keeping of the past I would but the place of citizenship as the birthplace and the section, 'other information' I would put the birthplace."
Basically what I am saying is it is important for the ancestral home or heimat be be noted for each person when it is not obvious what it is. The only place for this in the familytree is in the 'other information' section, under residence.
I keep my genealogy in Legacy. With my Swiss research which I started 1 year ago I have been adding sources to every relation, that is 1000's of sources and I go back and enter the sources in my genealogy program, after reading so many records I have become quite proficient at reading the registers.
I have expanded on Busswil bei Melchnau to include other sections that pertain to that place. Writing is an evolving process, I wouldn't be afraid to change up the pages. They should be constantly changing an improving. For that reason not every page is not going to look exactly that same as the writing process evolves. Donjgen 07:54, 20 May 2014 (UTC)

maps

the maps on the wiki show the gemeiden as they are today. I would hope that there would be some out of copyright maps that we could use that show them as they were before 1900. Donjgen 08:05, 20 May 2014 (UTC)

Genealogies

currently says - (see here for article describing Swiss compiled genealogies)
replace with a descriptive sentence
There are numerous compiled genealogies that have been created since 1900; however, they need to verified by researching the parish registers since it has been proven that a percentage of them are inaccurate.

The following genealogies have been researched for Melchnau families:

  • This page was last modified on 20 May 2014, at 08:24.
  • This page has been accessed 460 times.