Difference between revisions of "Talk:How to Guess Where to Start"

From FamilySearch Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(add {{unresolved}})
(comments about inviting for users)
Line 1: Line 1:
== Wrong word used ==
+
== Wrong word used ==
{{unresolved|Requesting additional contributor input before rewording}}
+
 
I greatly deplore the use of the word 'guess' in these articles. A guess, as my dictionary says, is "a judgment or opinion without sufficient evidence or grounds" and it has nothing whatever to do with good genealogical research. Some other word should be found. [[User:AnthonyJCamp|AnthonyJCamp]] 18:25, 9 September 2011 (UTC).
+
{{unresolved|Requesting additional contributor input before rewording}} I greatly deplore the use of the word 'guess' in these articles. A guess, as my dictionary says, is "a judgment or opinion without sufficient evidence or grounds" and it has nothing whatever to do with good genealogical research. Some other word should be found. [[User:AnthonyJCamp|AnthonyJCamp]] 18:25, 9 September 2011 (UTC).  
  
 
:I agree with Anthony. A "guess" to me suggests a complete stab in the dark, while the articles in the very least are talking about "educated guesses" or even working out a prediction for a piece of missing information based on the information already found. So would these articles better reflect the skill needed if renamed?  
 
:I agree with Anthony. A "guess" to me suggests a complete stab in the dark, while the articles in the very least are talking about "educated guesses" or even working out a prediction for a piece of missing information based on the information already found. So would these articles better reflect the skill needed if renamed?  
:* How to '''Decide''' Where to Start
+
:*How to '''Decide''' Where to Start  
:** '''Predict''' a spelling variation for every name on that family group
+
:**'''Predict''' a spelling variation for every name on that family group  
:** '''Predict''' a place for every event on that family group
+
:**'''Predict''' a place for every event on that family group  
:** '''Predict''' a date for every event on that family group
+
:**'''Predict''' a date for every event on that family group  
:** '''Predict''' the easiest (and hardest) person and event to research on that family group
+
:**'''Predict''' the easiest (and hardest) person and event to research on that family group  
:** '''Predict''' the best record types to use for finding information about any person’s event on that family group
+
:**'''Predict''' the best record types to use for finding information about any person’s event on that family group  
 
:This is just a suggestion, I'd be interested to hearing other alternatives or even why "Guess" is the best term to use. --[[User:Cottrells|Steve]] {{toolbar|[[User talk:Cottrells|talk]]|[[Special:Contributions/Cottrells|contribs]]}} 14:36, 10 September 2011 (UTC)
 
:This is just a suggestion, I'd be interested to hearing other alternatives or even why "Guess" is the best term to use. --[[User:Cottrells|Steve]] {{toolbar|[[User talk:Cottrells|talk]]|[[Special:Contributions/Cottrells|contribs]]}} 14:36, 10 September 2011 (UTC)
 +
 +
:How do we reach the inexperienced, the tentatively interested? Whatever words are used need to be inviting and give confidence to increase skills. I agree that an educated guess is probably better than just guessing.[[User:AdkinsWH|AdkinsWH]] 20:29, 20 December 2011 (UTC)

Revision as of 20:29, 20 December 2011

Wrong word used

This question or concern is currently unresolved.
Requesting additional contributor input before rewording
I greatly deplore the use of the word 'guess' in these articles. A guess, as my dictionary says, is "a judgment or opinion without sufficient evidence or grounds" and it has nothing whatever to do with good genealogical research. Some other word should be found. AnthonyJCamp 18:25, 9 September 2011 (UTC).
I agree with Anthony. A "guess" to me suggests a complete stab in the dark, while the articles in the very least are talking about "educated guesses" or even working out a prediction for a piece of missing information based on the information already found. So would these articles better reflect the skill needed if renamed?
  • How to Decide Where to Start
    • Predict a spelling variation for every name on that family group
    • Predict a place for every event on that family group
    • Predict a date for every event on that family group
    • Predict the easiest (and hardest) person and event to research on that family group
    • Predict the best record types to use for finding information about any person’s event on that family group
This is just a suggestion, I'd be interested to hearing other alternatives or even why "Guess" is the best term to use. --Steve (talk| contribs) 14:36, 10 September 2011 (UTC)
How do we reach the inexperienced, the tentatively interested? Whatever words are used need to be inviting and give confidence to increase skills. I agree that an educated guess is probably better than just guessing.AdkinsWH 20:29, 20 December 2011 (UTC)